GNC vs Bodybuilding.com: Affiliate Program Comparison

Side-by-side comparison of GNC and Bodybuilding.com — commission rates, cookie duration, payment terms, and the bottom line on which one pays affiliates more.

The Verdict

Based on 3 measurable factors. Best program depends on your audience and traffic style.

GNC0 wins
Bodybuilding.com2 wins
  • Higher Commission Rate: Bodybuilding.com (GNC 5% vs Bodybuilding.com 5-15%)
  • Longer Cookie Duration: Bodybuilding.com (7 days vs 9 days)
  • =Lower Minimum Payout: Tied ($50 vs $50)
Feature
G
GNC
B
Bodybuilding.com
Commission Rate5%5-15%
Commission Type
Percentage
Percentage
Cookie Duration7 days9 days
Minimum Payout$50$50
Payment MethodsDirect Deposit, CheckDirect Deposit, Check
Category
Health & Fitness
Health & Fitness
Best ForN/AHigh Commissions
Pros
  • Trusted brand name
  • Wide product selection
  • High repeat purchases
  • Both online and retail
  • Largest fitness community
  • Up to 15% on some products
  • Wide product selection
  • Strong brand trust
Cons
  • 5% commission is low
  • 7-day cookie is short
  • Competitive supplement space
  • Short 9-day cookie
  • Commission varies by product
  • Competitive fitness niche

Frequently Asked Questions

Which has a higher commission, GNC or Bodybuilding.com?

GNC pays 5%, while Bodybuilding.com pays 5-15%. The right choice depends on your audience: percentage-based commissions tend to pay more on high-ticket products, while flat-rate commissions are more predictable on lower-priced items.

What's the cookie duration for GNC vs Bodybuilding.com?

GNC offers a 7 day cookie, Bodybuilding.com offers 9 days. Longer cookie windows give you a better chance to earn commission when buyers research before purchasing.

Which affiliate program is better for beginners?

Beginners typically benefit from programs with lower minimum payouts and more payment method options. Bodybuilding.com has the lower minimum payout, which means faster access to earnings while you ramp up traffic.

Can I promote both GNC and Bodybuilding.com?

In most cases yes — affiliate programs don't typically forbid you from being part of competing programs. Always check the terms of service for any exclusivity clauses, especially for premium tier affiliates.

More Health & Fitness Comparisons

See all health & fitness affiliate programs ranked.

Best Health & Fitness Affiliate Programs

AffiliateRoll AI

How can we help?

Welcome to AffiliateRoll

Find the best affiliate programs, get recommendations, or reach out to our team.